It's not uncommon for PR to be sticky or gooy around the top or outer edges of the blank after a day in the pressure tank. It's build that way to allow for multiple pours to adhere to itself. Also, The tank is full of compressed air which is colder, so leaving the blanks I. Longer won't necessarily remove the tackiness. I usually take my blanks out after 20-24 hours and then let sit in direct sunlight or next to the hot air duct for a second day. If it's cold outside, you can keep the blanks inside and near the window or inside the tank with the lid off and a clamp light positioned over it to creat a lightbulb oven. It will cure the tackiness after a couple hours of getting warm and then cooling to room temp for the day.
If the blanks are soft through the middle and squishy I would guess the resin was not mixed enough. Another suggestion, warm your resin to around 80-90 degrees prior to adding the catalyst. It will stir and mix easier. Hotter than that will cause it to cure quickly leaving brittle blanks. I only mix 2-3 drops per ounce to keep the cured resin less brittle. Some have said they put the blanks in an oven to finish curing. I would not recommend that. Not only will you amplify the odor but you will make the resin more brittle and harder to turn without exploding. I hope some of this helps you out. Don't give up. You'll find your routine and it will all work out!