I am unhappy with UPS, almost everything they deliver has been crushed and contents broken. I avoid when I can. FedEx is better and is what I use for large packages.
I've seen the pictures and videos of the UPS guys throwing boxes at Christmas time.
Regarding FedEx - Here is a relevant story:
In October of 2003, I shipped my very expensive musical instrument (retail $14,500 now) to another state for use with a well known Chamber Orchestra where a Compact Disc recording was being made of a well known composer's music. Despite the rarity of this instrument, I owned a very nice one that was available for rent for these kinds of events.
I shipped the horn with $10,500 valuation/coverage (essentially insurance) via FedEx and it arrived without a problem. When the orchestra was done with the instrument, they shipped it back via FedEx. It made it as far as Chicago and then disappeared off of their tracking system. I contacted FedEx and reported not receiving the instrument, and they began their pointless and hopeless search for the box - including the location in Utah that accepts boxes that have "lost their labels" and must research the contents to find the owners of the packages.
All attempts to locate the instrument failed, and FedEx decided to send me $4200 to cover the cost of a mint condition, customized, top of the line rare instrument that could not be replaced for under $10,000 (including all accessories and case). Their explanation for not honoring the valuation/coverage was that, despite a letter from the manufacturer of the instrument (which gave me the horn to use as one of their Performing Artists) stating the value of the instrument, a copy of the receipt for the custom work done on the horn, a copy of all receipts for accessories (over $900), FedEx refused to honor any of the letters or receipts and made a unilateral decision to devalue the horn by 10% per year of ownership (age of instrument) - because, as they claimed, no book value for this instrument could be located anywhere. According to them, because it was six years old, they knocked $6000 off of the previously paid for valuation/coverage. They claim it isn't insurance - but my attorney tells me that it really is.
I won't go into any additional details about what happened directly following the problem - but I thought everything was concluded. Until this this past fall when a friend coincidentally purchased the instrument from eBay - from a company that sells items that were never claimed via shipping companies. This company (which will remain unidentified), put me in touch with their supplier, and the supplier turned out to be the very company that allegedly receives boxes that have "lost their labels" and they research the contents to find out who the owners are. Despite my name being in the case, on the accessories, and despite my claim to FedEx, this company held the instrument for two years and then sold it to the eBay company.
End result? I was lucky. I contacted this company and told them that I would be pursuing a claim against them within two weeks if the problem could not be resolved. At first, they wanted me to return the $4200 to FedEx - but I told them that not only had FedEx screwed me with the reduced amount, I was without income for a long period of time because of loss of rental and inability to accept performance opportunities with the instrument. We eventually came to a nice resolution, and I am satisfied that my friend and I came out happy.
I now only use FedEx when a dealer of my products asks me to. However, based on this experience, I don't trust the company. There isn't anything you can do if they singularly decide not to honor the coverage you paid for! You are left with no choice but to file a legal complaint. Because of their size and wealth - the lawsuit could take years and drain your bank account. I prevailed only because the friend contacted me to tell me about her new instrument - and we figured out it was mine!
I hope this little story serves to alert anyone out there to consider all possibilities prior to using any particular company for shipping!
Best wishes,
Roger Garrett
However