I can't tell, is it the cup that turned white or the resin? Some of the clear plastic cups I use, the bottom area of the cup turns white like that too, but the resin itself is completely un-affected and still totally clear. If the resin turned white, you have a problem, but if only the bottom of the cup itself turned white, you have no problems.
If it is like Curtis said..mis packaged, then one of the two parts should be white in the container should it not? I have never purchased the white alumilite before.
If you have to send it back, it will be no problem, they will work with you and send you a label to send it back and send you a new one, but the bummer part is that they will charge you for the new batch until they get their old batch back and then they will credit the double charge.