wudnhed
Member
Haven't gotten any on the Pen Makers Challenge, any comments? What about judges, any volunteers?
Feedback?
- Thread starter wudnhed
- Start date
Signed-In Members Don't See This Ad
Signed-In Members Don't See This Ad
Scott
Member
Hi Becca!
Actually, I think you have the Challenge pretty well set up! I would not announce who the judges are, as no matter who you chose, someone will be unhappy. Those of us working on the Bash planning would probably be fine judges, any one of us. You may want to keep this simple, and have yourself and one other person judge each of the challenges. You can choose a different person for each challenge to mix things up. As you get entries, E-Mail them to the other person judging, and ask them to tell you their top three without ranking them in order. Then you rank them in order based on how well they achieved the goals of the challenge, and announce the winners. What do you think?
Scott.
Actually, I think you have the Challenge pretty well set up! I would not announce who the judges are, as no matter who you chose, someone will be unhappy. Those of us working on the Bash planning would probably be fine judges, any one of us. You may want to keep this simple, and have yourself and one other person judge each of the challenges. You can choose a different person for each challenge to mix things up. As you get entries, E-Mail them to the other person judging, and ask them to tell you their top three without ranking them in order. Then you rank them in order based on how well they achieved the goals of the challenge, and announce the winners. What do you think?
Scott.
DocStram
Member
I agree. From past experience, it appears that all of the IAP members are fine with not knowing who the actual judges are .... and, more importantly, nobody ever seems to moan or groan or whine about the judging. Just knowing that the judges are anonymous .... seems to work fine.
Scott
Member
Becca, if the judging scheme above sounds good, I would volunteer to be a judge one week.
Scott.
Scott.
wudnhed
Member
Thanks Scott, how about the 1st week, I'm still working on recruits 
Scott
Member
Sounds good to me! Who else will volunteer?
Scott.
Scott.
melogic
Member
Put me down as a judge if you need me Becca.