Crack happens

Signed-In Members Don't See This Ad

qquake

Member
Joined
Feb 8, 2004
Messages
5,042
Location
Northern California
This is Roman olive. I should have cleaned out the tube, but rarely have a problem like this.
 

Attachments

  • crack01.jpg
    crack01.jpg
    125.1 KB · Views: 93
  • crack02.jpg
    crack02.jpg
    136.5 KB · Views: 97
Signed-In Members Don't See This Ad
I've had issues with olive also. I made a bangle bracelet from and olive cutting board and had cracks appear months later even under a ca finish.
 
Oh man, I hope not. I turned a bunch of bodies from the same wood.
 

Attachments

  • 200.jpg
    200.jpg
    160.8 KB · Views: 95
  • 201.jpg
    201.jpg
    203.9 KB · Views: 85
That stinks. I've had similar problems on occasion. I've gotten into the habit of making sure the tubes are clean and I chamfer them a bit with a chamfering tool before assembly. I also am in the habit of smearing a little bit of wax around the inside of the tube just before I press the pieces in. I don't know if it really adds the lubricity that I expect from it, but at least it makes me feel better. Olive is such a pretty wood. I hope you have better luck on the rest! - Dave
 
Is it possible for blanks to crack due to cooling from the heat generated during sanding/finishing? I had some very fine hairline cracks (barely visible) in two rollerball kits I made. They appeared before I even assembled, and I wasn't really sure how...I have become overly careful assembling, as the pen assembly/disassembly rig I have, which has a holed plastic stop on one end and a metal cylinder on the other, has been marring the nibs when I put them in. So I never over-crank anything, but sometimes I still notice cracks in my turned blanks. Only thing I could think is maybe heating and cooling was allowing the wood to pull apart?
 
That stinks. I've had similar problems on occasion. I've gotten into the habit of making sure the tubes are clean and I chamfer them a bit with a chamfering tool before assembly. I also am in the habit of smearing a little bit of wax around the inside of the tube just before I press the pieces in. I don't know if it really adds the lubricity that I expect from it, but at least it makes me feel better. Olive is such a pretty wood. I hope you have better luck on the rest! - Dave

Never thought of waxing the tubes. I have some of that screw wax, which is very thin and goes a long way...wonder if that would help.
 
I think in my case, it was a matter of not cleaning the tube before I assembled. I should get into the habit of doing that, but in my defense, I rarely have pens crack.
 
Is it possible for blanks to crack due to cooling from the heat generated during sanding/finishing? I had some very fine hairline cracks (barely visible) in two rollerball kits I made. They appeared before I even assembled, and I wasn't really sure how...I have become overly careful assembling, as the pen assembly/disassembly rig I have, which has a holed plastic stop on one end and a metal cylinder on the other, has been marring the nibs when I put them in. So I never over-crank anything, but sometimes I still notice cracks in my turned blanks. Only thing I could think is maybe heating and cooling was allowing the wood to pull apart?
The simple answer is... YES. Heat is not your friend, and any unnecessary heat from drilling/turning/finishing/polishing should be minimized. I, try to slow down. Repeatedly clean my drill every 1/4", wipe with water if hot. And the rest of the process goes patiently while monitoring heat. Different timbers will react differently. Experience will teach you what you do not know.
 
Is it possible for blanks to crack due to cooling from the heat generated during sanding/finishing? I had some very fine hairline cracks (barely visible) in two rollerball kits I made. They appeared before I even assembled, and I wasn't really sure how...I have become overly careful assembling, as the pen assembly/disassembly rig I have, which has a holed plastic stop on one end and a metal cylinder on the other, has been marring the nibs when I put them in. So I never over-crank anything, but sometimes I still notice cracks in my turned blanks. Only thing I could think is maybe heating and cooling was allowing the wood to pull apart?
Yes , if
The simple answer is... YES. Heat is not your friend, and any unnecessary heat from drilling/turning/finishing/polishing should be minimized. I, try to slow down. Repeatedly clean my drill every 1/4", wipe with water if hot. And the rest of the process goes patiently while monitoring heat. Different timbers will react differently. Experience will teach you what you do not know.
Cracking is a risk any time the wood gets hot enough that you can`t comfortably hold an uncalloused finger on it . Drill as Mark suggests , with a sharp bit . On very hard crack prone woods , I flood the hole with water every 1/4 inch . Don`t worry about flat work thinking that wood and water don`t mix . The wood did grow up with it , after all .
 
The simple answer is... YES. Heat is not your friend, and any unnecessary heat from drilling/turning/finishing/polishing should be minimized. I, try to slow down. Repeatedly clean my drill every 1/4", wipe with water if hot. And the rest of the process goes patiently while monitoring heat. Different timbers will react differently. Experience will teach you what you do not know.

Yes , if

Cracking is a risk any time the wood gets hot enough that you can`t comfortably hold an uncalloused finger on it . Drill as Mark suggests , with a sharp bit . On very hard crack prone woods , I flood the hole with water every 1/4 inch . Don`t worry about flat work thinking that wood and water don`t mix . The wood did grow up with it , after all .

Ah, I didn't even think about drilling. I wonder if the cracks actually happened then, and I only noticed them later. I do clear the bit flute frequently when drilling, but I wasn't paying much attention to heat. I did read (or watch) something about blanks (notably acrylic) expanding when drilling, and then contracting when cooling down, to the point where the tubes wouldn't fit. I hadn't experienced that problem, so I hadn't put much additional thought into drill heating.

I don't think I've gotten the wood hot enough that it was uncomfortably hot to my fingers while sanding. It has gotten fairly warm, maybe hotish, but not uncomfortable. I have had uncomfortably hot sandpaper when sanding bowls at too high of a speed, so I think I understand the temperature we are talking about. I have turned more acrylic/poly pens than wood at this point, I think, and I guess I'm probably a bit worried about melting such blanks!
 
Back
Top Bottom