Towbar15
Member
I'm just moved back to the states and was wondering if there is any difference between the two resins?
Thank you,
Jerry
Thank you,
Jerry
Castincraft clear casting resin vs silmar 41
- Thread starter Towbar15
- Start date
Signed-In Members Don't See This Ad
Signed-In Members Don't See This Ad
PenMan1
Member
I only use CastinCraft resin when I'm completely out of 41.
I come from a boating background where Silmar 404 (same as 41, except 404/401 has structural integrity, but doesn't cure completely clear), are an industry standard that every "glasser" knows how to use.
I likely prefer 41 because of the cost factor. I use a LOT of 41 and order it in VERY LARGE quantities. The way I buy Silmar, I can buy it for less than 1/10th the price of CastinCraft ( if my market stays where it is now, I'll likely go back to 5 gal. orders).
41 SEEMS TO set up quicker, with fewer bubbles. BUT, I've also had excellent results with CastinCraft. If I poured 4 or 5 blanks per week, the CastinCraft (with a 50% off coupon and FRESH CATALYST - usually Michael's catalyst is very old) might be a better value.
I haven't ordered a single gallon of S41 in years, but I think the gallon price is now about $30 plus hazmat shipping, whick makes it nearly $50 per gal. With a 50% off coupon and a sales tax ID, sometimes you can get a quart of CastinCraft for around $20. I've had excellent results with CastinCraft, it just seems to "set up" a little slower. Buying it at a craft store, rather than from a distributor could mean that it is older, accounting for the slower set up.
I hope this helps!
I come from a boating background where Silmar 404 (same as 41, except 404/401 has structural integrity, but doesn't cure completely clear), are an industry standard that every "glasser" knows how to use.
I likely prefer 41 because of the cost factor. I use a LOT of 41 and order it in VERY LARGE quantities. The way I buy Silmar, I can buy it for less than 1/10th the price of CastinCraft ( if my market stays where it is now, I'll likely go back to 5 gal. orders).
41 SEEMS TO set up quicker, with fewer bubbles. BUT, I've also had excellent results with CastinCraft. If I poured 4 or 5 blanks per week, the CastinCraft (with a 50% off coupon and FRESH CATALYST - usually Michael's catalyst is very old) might be a better value.
I haven't ordered a single gallon of S41 in years, but I think the gallon price is now about $30 plus hazmat shipping, whick makes it nearly $50 per gal. With a 50% off coupon and a sales tax ID, sometimes you can get a quart of CastinCraft for around $20. I've had excellent results with CastinCraft, it just seems to "set up" a little slower. Buying it at a craft store, rather than from a distributor could mean that it is older, accounting for the slower set up.
I hope this helps!
toyotaman
Member
Silmar 41 is a better quality resin and "Alot" more cost effective.
BSea
Member
I agree, and as long as you order less than 5 gallons, you don't have to pay a hazmat fee. The last time I ordered, I bought 3 gallons. The price was just ove $110 after shipping.
I think S41 is a bit less chippy than C&C too. I have a gallon of C&C and we are in prime pouring season! I have a clunky old HF drill press so after the pour, I just put it on the platform, hit the switch and let 'er wiggle all the bubbles out for me! Always had good results with C&C once you get the hang of casting. Coupons in almost every Sunday paper.