Thank you very much for the feedback, its been very useful. To answer some of the questions -
Ruth, Axis is an exotic deer originally from India. Their pelts have the pattern and coloration similar to a whitetail fawn in that they have white spots on them. In addition, they tend to be larger than whitetail (on the order of 1.5 times for equivalent age/sex). As to their antlers, they tend to have much larger circumference and over all length than whitetail. Also, the bark tends to be thinner and the "marrow" tends to be much smaller. The result is that turners have much more "antler heart" to take advantage of and its is much whiter than whitetail. In fact, I think that it polishes up close to what you could expect from ivory. On top of that, it drills/turns easier and doesn't have anywhere near the stench whitetail does(at least to me).
Billy - the prices you listed are what I was seeing for racks on eBay as well. I'm thinking of taking it one level further and "milling" the antler in prep for pen making.
Joe - I'm considering selling it. In addition, the reason that I'm coming to this forum is that I don't want to sell these on eBay as the market for these is pretty specific and I would rather not get lost in the "shuffle". In addition, there have been a couple threads lately that were not very positive about purchasing pen stuff from eBay and one seller in particular.
Again, thanks to everyone for your comments. I will post some sample pictures later today to continue the discussion a little as I'm getting some great guidance here. Then in probably a week or so, I'll post in the individual classifieds with an initial lot to see how things go. If it goes well, I may post regular lots.
Based on feedback and some of my research, here is what I'm generally thinking about pricing. Please feel free to add additional comments or suggestions.
Fresh Antler (this is recent drops or from harvested deer)
Base cut including "cap" (this is where the antler connects to the skull) 6-8 inches and averaging 3/4-7/8 inch diameter - $10 ea
Naturally straight cut 5-6 inches averaging close to 3/4 diameter - $6 ea
Straighted cut (boiled and then straighted) 5-6 in w/ 5/8 to 3/4 diameter - $4
Tips and bits $1 a piece or included free in multi piece orders
Weathered antler - same dimensions, but 10% to 50% of fresh depending upon the quality.
Shipping would be USPS priority flat rate where possible, actual shipping where not. This of course could also be buyer's preference.
So, keep the comments coming and thanks once again.